…drinking clubs or support groups? You decide.

From the Guardian:

 

Rise of male student support groups sparks row at British universities• Support groups explore masculinity as a concept
• Critics claim societies a front for ‘macho activities’

Caroline Davies The Guardian, Monday 23 November 2009 larger | smaller Article history
A male student at Oxford University, where he can join MC-O should he wish to explore masculinity with his male peers. Photograph: Oli Scarff/Getty Images

After decades of feminism, equal rights and “women-only” support networks, a lower, deeper voice is attempting to make itself heard at some of Britain’s leading universities.

Male students are “manning-up”, setting up men’s groups to celebrate and explore the concept of masculinity amid accusations of sexism and gender stereotyping.

Manchester University has created the first official MENS Society - Masculinity Exploring Networking and Support - despite outrage from critics who claim the existence of such a group undermines women’s ability to speak out for equality.

Meanwhile, at Oxford University the formation of Man Collective - Oxford (MC-O), launched “as a response to the current state of masculinity” has been branded “reactionary and ridiculous”.

Detractors allege they are just a front for macho activities and beer-drinking marathons, but supporters insist they are essential as young men struggle to cope with the pressures of being a man in the modern world.

Alex Linsley, 20, founder of MC-O, said: “There is so much conflicting information for men. There is massive confusion as to what being a man means, and how to be a good man. Should you be the sensitive all-caring, perhaps the ‘feminised’ man? Or should you be the hard, take no crap from anybody kind of figure?

“Neither of those are particularly useful paradigms. But there’s perhaps things we could learn from both perspectives”.

Men, who could feel pressured to “man-up” in a mixed gender environment, might feel less vulnerable discussing such issues in a male-only setting.

The Merton college student admits launching his organisation with the testosterone-fuelled invitation - “Have you got balls? Literally. If you have how does that make you feel?” - has drawn stinging criticism.

Given that men already dominate political and economic life, British society didn’t need “much more celebration of masculinity,” claimed one critic.

Kat Wall, the Oxford University’s student union vice president for women, accused him of gender stereotyping but welcomed the debate and hoped he would work with the women’s campaign to “facilitate a discussion forum on the issue of masculinity”.

But Linsley, an economics and management student who started MC-O after being struck by the number of 18- to 25-year-old males committing suicide in Oxford, has also received positive feedback.

While self-improvement among women was common with magazines bursting with advice, there was little for men, was the message. “Do you expect men to mysteriously find their own way alone?” questioned one supporter on the Cherwell university newspaper website.

“I want to create this forum for men, so men can learn from each other and discuss these issues and make a positive step forward,” said Linsley.

In Manchester, the MENS Society, which despite its name has women among its 306 members, claims it highlights not just masculinity issues, but also raises funds and awareness for men’s mental health, testicular and prostate cancer as well as male rape and domestic violence issues.

Its campaign for official ratification from the student union’s societies committee has provoked furious debate. Originally called the Men’s Society, it has now agreed to the MENS compromise. Founder Ben Wild, 21, a politics and modern history student, said he was “relieved that the societies committee has acknowledged the importance and promising benefits of this new society, the first of it’s kind in a UK university”.

“Why have one? Because so little was being done on raising awareness on issues specific to men, such as male depression, which occurs because they can’t live up to this very idealised traditional masculine role,” he said.

Such arguments hold little sway with opponents, however.

Olivia Bailey, NUS national women’s officer, said: “Discrimination against men on the basis of gender is so unusual as to be non-existent, so what exactly will a men’s society do?”

“To suggest that men need a specific space to be ‘men’ is ludicrous, when everywhere you turn you will find male-dominated spaces,” she added.

Caitriona Rylance, chair of Manchester Communist Students, said that while the society now claimed to be about “self-betterment” it’s original aims were “Top Gear shows, gadget fairs, beer-drinking marathons and Iron Man competitions”.

Wild responded: “There has been so much false information peddled. I’m teetotal, and our first event was a sober pub crawl. And we’ve compromised on our beard-growing contests to make it more inclusive.”

Professor Marilyn Davidson, an expert in diversity and equality at the Manchester Business School said: “It is interesting that this is happening. And there is an obvious need. One of the problems men have is that they don’t have the support networks when they are under stress that women do.

“If we were talking about business and all-male clubs, they were the gatekeepers who were stopping women entering. But I don’t think these groups are doing that. It’s not us against them. It’s just about supporting each other.”

Patrick Leman, from Royal Holloway University of London, said: “In some senses it is to be welcomed, because it is good that young men reflect on who they are and what they should be doing. That sort of reflected self-awareness is not something that is particularly associated with men. But I went to Oxford, and it could, of course, just turn into another awful drinking society.”

However, Martin Daubney, 39, editor of the lads’ magazine Loaded, was contemptuous. “I don’t think men are remotely confused about what it takes to be a man. They just get on and do it. My generation would not sit round and build a website about being confused. It’s complete navel-gazing bullshit.”

 

Tags: british mens society

This entry was posted on Monday, November 23rd, 2009 at 9:29 am. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.